Book Now
No. 02 The Reading List 10 minute read

An overworked heart.

Cyril Conroy, the father in Ann Patchett's The Dutch House, built, worked, smoked, and never spoke of his grief. An Ayurvedic doctor in Burlington, Ontario, reads his heart the way she reads a patient's, and explains why the thin, restless man is the one nobody watches.

A note before we begin: this essay gives away an important turn in The Dutch House. If you are planning to read the novel, or are in the middle of it, you may want to come back to this afterwards.

Cyril Conroy dies suddenly, of a heart attack, in the middle of a working day. In Ann Patchett's The Dutch House he has gone to check on repairs on the top floor of a building that is not yet finished. Because it is unfinished there is no elevator, and no air conditioning, and it is a very hot day. The only light in the stairwell comes from lamps running off a generator, which makes the heat worse. He climbs on foot. He has a bad knee from the war, and he is, by his own admission, out of shape, and every flight is a struggle. He does not reach the top.

Nobody in the novel sees it coming. That is the point I want to sit with. There was no illness. There was no diagnosis. This was a man who had overworked himself and carried too much stress.

Who Cyril was

Patchett gives us the outline of him quickly. He grew up with nothing. He came back from the war and started buying buildings, one and then another, until he owned a good part of the town. He collected the rent himself, on a Saturday, with his young son beside him, because he did not trust anyone else to do it and because he liked it. He bought the Dutch House with cash, as a surprise for his wife, and it was the wrong surprise. She hated the house, and after a while she left him and the children and went away to serve the poor. He never spoke of it. He never explained it to the children. He got up the next day and went to work.

He smoked, as most men of his time did. He limped. He ate what was put in front of him. He remarried a woman who wanted the house more than she wanted him. And every day, on that knee, he went to look at his buildings.

Patchett describes him in one line: "He was tall and thin with weathered skin." I want to hold on to that, because it matters more than it looks. Everyone knows the heart patient who is heavy. The man carrying extra weight, the one whose doctor has been warning him for years, is the person we picture when we hear the words heart disease. In Ayurveda that is the kapha heart, and it is real. But nobody looks twice at the tall, thin, restless man who never sits down. That is the vata heart, and it is the one that stops without warning. Cyril Conroy is that man exactly.

What Ayurveda means by the heart

Ayurveda has a word for the heart, hridaya, and it means more than the pump. The classical texts describe it as the place where the body keeps its reserve. That reserve has its own name, ojas. Think of ojas as the deep fuel underneath your daily energy, the store that decides whether you can keep going for forty years or only for forty months.

Ojas is built slowly. It comes from food that is properly digested, from sleep, from rest that is real rest, and from being loved. It is spent slowly too, in ordinary living. The trouble starts when it is spent faster than it is made.

The classical physicians wrote down what drains it, and the list is not mysterious. Overwork. Skipping meals. Worry. Grief. Fear. Going without sleep. Dry, harsh things taken into the body. Read that list once more, with Cyril Conroy in mind, and you will see that he is on every line of it.

The three things that emptied him

What drained the reserve
One
The work
Irregular hours, no grounding. Feeds Vata, the wind, which disturbs the heart's rhythm first.
Two
The smoking
Dry and hot. Dries the channels and heats them; the wind rises further, the channels harden.
Three
The grief
Tears held back. Not spent, so carried, and it collects in the weakest spot.
Hridaya, the heart, where the body keeps ojas, its reserve.
Spent faster than it is made, every day, for years.

The first is the work itself. Ayurveda describes three forces in the body, and the one that governs movement, the nerves, the pulse, and the mind that will not stop is Vata dosha. Vata is the wind. It rises when life is irregular: when meals are at odd hours, when sleep is short, when the day is all rushing around with no grounding. A man who is always driving to the next building, always climbing to the next floor, is feeding the wind, and the wind, in the texts, is what disturbs the heart's rhythm first.

The second is the smoking. Ayurveda thinks about smoke the way it thinks about any dry, hot thing: it dries the body's channels and it heats them. Dryness is the wind's own quality; add it and the wind rises further. Heat, in a man already driven by ambition, is the fire on top of the fire. We know now, in the plainest medical terms, what cigarettes do to arteries. The classical language got there by a different road and arrived at the same place. The channels harden, the heart has to push against them, and the result is an overworked heart.

The third is the one I think Patchett cares about most, and the one my patients least expect me to ask about. Cyril's wife left him and he did not cry. Not in front of the children, not, as far as we are told, at all. He locked it, and went to work. Ayurveda has a very old and very specific teaching here: holding back tears is listed, alongside holding back other natural urges, as a cause of heart disease. Grief that is not spent has to be carried somewhere, and it collects in the weakest spot.

This is the part of Ayurveda that surprises people most. It looks at the person as a whole, not just the physical body. We look at the mental and emotional body too, because what is not resolved at that level very often creeps into the physical one. So in my consulting room we talk about the grief, and the trauma, and the thing that was never said. We look for the root cause, and we treat from there, not only from the chest.

Put the three together and you have a heart that has been asked, every day for years, to do more than it was being given the means to do. The staircase was not the cause. The staircase was the day the heart could simply not go on any further.

The staircase was not the cause. The staircase was the day the heart could simply not go on any further.

The man in my consulting room

I want to describe him — he is the one who has decided, on his own, to come. Something has frightened him a little: a friend the same age, a number on a blood test, a tightness he does not want to name. The man who is sent by his wife, and sits in the chair to keep the peace, I do not see. He is not interested in changing anything, he will nod and tell me he is following the plan when he is not, and it wastes his time and mine. The man who comes on his own is different, and he is worth every minute.

I do not check his pulse or his blood pressure straight away. In my initial Comprehensive Consultation, which is two hours long, and even in a one-hour follow-up, I wait for forty-five minutes to pass first, because the body needs that long in a quiet room before it stops running ahead of itself. With this man, forty-five minutes is often not enough. The pulse under my fingers is still going somewhere. It is quick, thin, and a little hard, like a wire. That is the wind. Underneath it, when I press deeper, the beat that should feel full and steady feels spent. That is the reserve, low.

He tells me he sleeps five hours and does not need more. He tells me he eats at his desk. He tells me the smoking is down to a few. He does not volunteer the thing that happened four years ago that he has not talked about. I ask him directly, because I need the full picture of what is going on, and I can already feel it in the room the same way Danny Conroy could feel it in the house.

None of this is a diagnosis of a heart attack. I want to be careful about that. Hearts stop in people who believe they have done everything right, and in people who have ignored the warning signs and the basic advice to eat wisely, to exercise, to stop smoking, and to reduce the stress. A pulse is not a prophecy. What I am describing is a pattern, and Ayurveda's whole usefulness is that it reads the pattern early, while there is still something to be done about it.

What could have been done

The remedy for an emptied reserve is not a miracle herb. It is the crucial things, done for long enough. Sleep, at a regular hour. Food eaten sitting down, warm, at roughly the same times each day. Oil on the body, which sounds strange to a Western ear and is one of the oldest treatments in the tradition for pacifying Vata dosha.

Most people know every item on that list. They still choose to ignore it, thinking, today is not the day. What I tell them is simple. Your body has been warning you for years. The knee you climb on anyway. The sleep you have decided you do not need. The cigarette that is only a few. The trauma and grief that was never fully expressed. It does not have to be a wife who left; a loss that nobody else thought was large can do the same work. Ayurveda's first rule is to read the body before reaching for the textbook, and the body was saying it all along.

A pulse is not a prophecy. What I am describing is a pattern, and Ayurveda's whole usefulness is that it reads the pattern early.

How Ayurveda cares for a heart

Heart health in Ayurveda is not a single prescription. It begins with the person in front of me and their constitution, because it is not only what you eat but whether you are eating for your body type, and how you eat, which matters just as much and which we spend real time on in a consultation. It includes the pulse, checked at every visit, so that I can feel whether the reserve is coming back and the immune system is strengthening, rather than guessing. It includes the tongue, which I look at every visit as well, because the tongue is a reflection of the whole body and shows me which parts of it are under stress, often before the person can tell me. It includes the mind: we talk about grief, about low mood, about the stress that a man like Cyril Conroy would have called normal. And it includes the tools the tradition has kept for two thousand years, herbs chosen for the individual, aromatherapy, and treatments timed to the body's own clock, all of them designed to do one thing, which is to let a heart rest and rebuild.

The best time to look after a heart is not when something goes wrong. It is well before that, in the years when the pulse is still only a little quick and the tiredness is still only a little deeper than it should be. That is the stage at which the work is quiet and the results are large. If you recognise yourself in the man on the stairs, or in the thin, restless father nobody worries about, that is the moment to come and sit down for two hours and let someone read what your body has been saying.

Cyril Conroy never did. His heart told him, in the only language it had, for twenty years, and nobody in the house could read it. Yours does not have to go unread. The two-hour Comprehensive Consultation at A-YUR-VEDA in Burlington is where that reading begins: pulse, tongue, constitution, and the conversation nobody else has time for. Book it before the stairs, not after.

Comprehensive Consultation · Two hours
Pulse, tongue, constitution, and the conversation nobody else has time for.
Book a consultation
Physician-led · Burlington, Ontario · Online worldwide

Forward this to a friend →

About the writer

Dr. Arlini Singh is the owner and founder of A-YUR-VEDA, an integrated medical clinic in Burlington, Ontario, where she practises Ayurvedic medicine. Alongside her clinical work she writes A-YUR-VEDA Journal. She reads more than she writes, and writes only when something has finished settling.

Continue the column
Previously  ·  No. 01

Before the diagnosis →

The Dutch House, read through kriyakala.

Back to the column

Return to The Reading List →